• Banner 3
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 1

Welcome to Matt the Miller's

Mills the Miller's is a gastropub located in Carmel, IN, offering a diverse menu with options for pescatarians, vegans, and limited vegetarians. The restaurant provides a range of utilities, including outdoor seating, waiter service, and a full bar. Customers have praised the upscale decor, quick service, and delicious dishes like Nashville Hot Chicken Flatbread and Matt's meatloaf. The friendly atmosphere, cozy ambiance, and attentive staff make it a recommended spot for family gatherings or lunch/dinner outings. Despite some minor issues with overly sauced dishes, Matt the Miller's remains a popular choice for a satisfying meal experience.

Matt the Miller's: Reviews & Ratings

Karen O.
Karen O.

Had a pleasantly nice lunch at this tavern. The decor is upscale and service was quick and on point. We both got the lunch special which is $14 each. I got Potato soup and Nashville Hot Chicken Flatbread and hubs got The Miller salad and the Nashville hot chicken flatbread. We both were pleasantly surprised with how good the food was however, I will caution somebody if they don't like hot food. This was a little hot so we got some ranch to help cool down our mouth. I would definitely try this place again.

Elizabeth M.
Elizabeth M.

Decided to try a new place for dinner tonight... We ordered the pretzel bites to start...OMG, they were so good and the sauces, sweet mustard and a creamy garlic aioli were amazing! For entrees, my husband ordered a NYStrip with cheesy grit cake, asparagus and sautéed mushrooms...everything was cooked to perfection and tasty...I ordered the Matt's meatloaf, it came with Texas toast, mashed potatoes and a bbq style sauce and broccoli....so good and I have leftovers for lunch tomorrow!! Our server was great, very attentive checking on us and the atmosphere of the restaurant is cozy, and family friendly. We definitely recommend and we will definitely be going back to try other items in the menu!!

Phil B.
Phil B.

I don't think we've ever been here when we've not been here for brunch. I was craving Salmon and a search in Yelp pulled up a few places including here. Got reservations on Open Table. We walked in and were sat in the bar area. I ordered the Salmon with Mashed Potatoes, sautéed spinach and maple glaze. The menu said pumpkin seeds but I think they used sunflower seeds. They need to be careful substituting like that. Some people have sunflower oil allergies. Husband ordered a steak with Yukon gold potatoes. The salmon was perfect. As was the spinach and mashed potatoes. Totally emptied my plate. Husband said the steak was good and I know the potatoes were good. We ordered dessert to go. Banana Cream Pie and Chocolate Mousse Cake. Wasn't able to get the Banana Cream Pie. They were out of the crust to make it. We did the tiny miniature piece of Chocolate Mousse Cake. Husband ate it at home later and said it was ok. Service was very good and the food we got was all pretty spot on.

beth h.
beth h.

Was traveling and was looking for a place to grab a bite on our road trip. SO glad I found this place! The atmosphere is trendy & welcoming. They have a great patio by a fountain too. My husband & I opted to sit inside because was a 'lil chilly. We were doing a quick hit so decided to belly up to the bar & the staff was SO incredibly nice & attentive. Special shout out to Casey. He is a gem! Nicest server ever! I had the Margarita Flatbread & Matt's salad with blue cheese dressing. It was so delicious I ordered a salad to go for lunch the next day! My husband ordered the prime rib sammie w/ sweet potato fries ( side of horseradish) he raved about it & devoured it! I am definitely going to make this a regular stop when we pass through town! Thanks Matt Miller's for creating such a great place!!! Cheers !

Carolyn W.
Carolyn W.

Mia took care of us at this visit. I am not a bun girl, but wanted the burger. I explained this to her and she communicated to the kitchen. Below is the beautiful result. Matt the Millers delivers! By the way, we were seated in a small booth in the bar. I totally recommend! Pub/restaurant atmosphere.

Mike K.
Mike K.

It has been a while since I have been here, but it was like I remember. Food and drinks are always good. Presentation solid. Staff attentive. Food arriving quickly even if they are busy.

Catherine W.
Catherine W.

I'm giving this a four, although my most recent visit was pretty rough. To start with the good: this is a great place to go for appetizers and drinks (just not on a night someone good is playing at the Palladium because, good luck.) Drinks are pretty solid. For the area, it's pretty affordable, too. We stopped in for brunch a few months ago and it was surprisingly delicious. Overall, we live close and this is in the rotation of places we'll go on a whim, especially on a nice day when the patio is open. That being said, something changed recently and the food is saturated in sauce. Sugary sauce, at that. We got the ahi tuna appetizer - it came drowning in sweet sauce. The same went for the flatbread. We couldn't finish our food, paid our bill, and grabbed to go somewhere else on the way home. This could have easily been just a bad day in the kitchen, so I wouldn't rule this place out entirely. Overall, a decent neighborhood place to pop into!

Andrew R.
Andrew R.

This is a great place for a meal with a larger group. The menu has a good amount of options without being overwhelming. I ordered the turkey club with sweet potatoes and it was all delicious! I also appreciated that all our food came out at the same time, even with a group of 8. I will say, someone in my group got the Margherita flatbread and described it as a "soggy cracker with tomatoes on it" and honestly, it looked disgusting. So yeah I'd just avoid the flatbreads. Otherwise, this place was great!

Satoya B.
Satoya B.

This was my first time here. We came for our work Christmas party. I got the mushroom truffle burger with sweet potato fries. I absolutely love sweet potato fries. The burger was cooked to perfection. I took the bun off the burger since I'm watching carbs. I like that they asked how you want it cooked. For it to be so many of us the severs and service was great. I like how they had 2 waiters one had one side of the room and the other took the other side.

Location

Welcome to Matt the Miller's, a gastropub located in Carmel, IN, offering a diverse menu with options for everyone. This veteran-owned establishment prides itself on its upscale decor, quick service, and a cozy atmosphere that is family-friendly.

From Potato soup to Nashville Hot Chicken Flatbread, Matt the Miller's offers a range of delicious dishes that will tantalize your taste buds. Customer reviews rave about the pretzel bites, NY Strip steak, Matt's meatloaf, Margarita Flatbread, and more. The attention to detail in the food preparation and the attentive service from the staff make dining here a memorable experience.

Whether you're in the mood for a hearty meal like the Salmon with Mashed Potatoes or a lighter option like the Matt's salad, there is something on the menu for everyone. The ambiance of the restaurant is trendy and welcoming, with outdoor seating available for those who prefer to dine al fresco.

Matt the Miller's also caters to dietary preferences, with Pescatarian, Vegan, and Limited Vegetarian options available. The restaurant is wheelchair accessible, offers QR code menus for convenience, and accepts various payment methods, including cryptocurrency.

Overall, Matt the Miller's is a standout gastropub that delivers on quality, taste, and service. Whether you're stopping by for a quick meal or a leisurely dinner, this establishment is sure to leave a lasting impression. Make sure to try out their Happy Hour specials and explore the diverse menu offerings for a culinary adventure you won't soon forget.